Many Blast SEC for Denying Bitcoin ETF Proposal: Here’s Why
For years, crypto financial services firms across the U.S. have been trying their hand at launching publicly-traded Bitcoin funds (ETFs).
Unfortunately for these hopefuls, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has long not agreed with these firms’ assertions that the cryptocurrency market is ready for its own regulated, tradable fund.
This was confirmed to be the case yet again when the financial regulator last week denied a proposal for a Bitcoin ETF, angering many in this community and even triggering an SEC commissioner to express her disapproval for this move.
SEC Denies Yet Another Bitcoin ETF Proposal
Wilshire Phoenix — one of the leading companies in the Bitcoin ETF race — on January 26th heard back from the SEC after months of waiting and six amendments made to its application. the SEC cited potential market manipulation and investor protection concerns for the denial.
Many were immediately taken aback by the response. Wilshire Phoenix said the following on the matter:
“We made every effort to get the SEC’s attention on this important issue, including undertaking extensive analysis that was made available to the SEC staff, submitting key data, and offering to provide additional information to facilitate the listing of a much needed regulated bitcoin-related ETP in the United States. Unfortunately, the Order shows that all of these efforts did not receive the SEC’s full attention.”
SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce even weighed in. In a statement of dissent towards the decision, the regulator, dubbed “Crypto Mom” for her friendly stance towards digital assets, said that the SEC’s handling of Bitcoin doesn’t line up with the agency’s handling of other markets:
“This line of disapprovals leads me to conclude that this Commission is unwilling to approve the listing of any product that would provide access to the market for bitcoin and that no filing will meet the ever-shifting standards that this Commission insists on applying to bitcoin-related products—and only to bitcoin-related products.”
Slowly But Surely?
Although Pierce is largely skeptical of a Bitcoin ETF making it to market anytime soon, there are signs that this industry is slowly making its way to a point where an ETF would be deemed viable.
Last year, NYDIG procured a green light from the SEC to launch the NYDIG Bitcoin Strategy Fund, a portfolio fund in the Stone Ridge Trust Vl. The fund invests in cash-settled Bitcoin futures contracts traded on Commodity Futures Trading Commission-approved exchanges.
According to a research note from Mike McGlone, a commodities strategist at Bloomberg Intelligence, shared by cryptocurrency commentator LightCrypto, the approval of the so-called interval fund from NYDIG improves the “odds of a Bitcoin ETF in 2020 to 50-50.” McGlone elaborated, writing:
“Approval shows that lobbying by issuers such as VanEck and Bitwise is starting to pay off.”